|
< Previous Post | Next Post >
Saturday, May 6. 2006Failure of Education: Franco-German reconciliation with Anti-AmericanismPosted by Editors in Transatlantic Relations on Saturday, May 6. 2006
Americans are not doing so well in geography, as Sirocco points out:
In 2002 a National Geographic-Roper study found 83 percent of Americans aged 18 to 24 unable to locate Afghanistan - the country whence the 9/11 attack originated and which the US had just invaded - when presented with four alternatives. Now a new such test reveals that nearly two-thirds of young adults cannot find Iraq on a map even after three years of war and more than 2,400 US deaths, at an estimated cost of $1-2 trillion.This is seems to be the result of a U.S.-centric highschool education. Now France and Germany have produced a joint history textbook, which apparently is not just Euro-centric, but also teaches a pro-European sentiment on the expense of the United States. Chirac and Schroeder started this initiative to contribute to further Franco-German reconciliation and mutual understanding by teaching history to French and German highschool students from both French and German perspectitves, as the publisher explains in German and French. The textbook was written by five German and five French historians. Guillaume Le Quintrec, who headed the French team, told The Times that the book contained "unashamedly pro-European ideology" and an underlying distrust of the United States. The textbook: starts in 1945, a convenient date that enables the authors to focus on "memories" of the Second World War rather than its causes. "The patriotic cult of victory has given way to a universal demand to remember the victims of the war," the work says. The next stage is the Cold War, where the US and the USSR are presented as broadly equivalent in moral terms. Both were engaged in an arms race described as "the balance of terror" and both sought to "impose themselves by an omnipresent propaganda" that involved "gross exaggerations and simplifications".While the book might describe different French and German perspectives, according to The Times it apparently ignores the US perspective and describes the EU as good multilateralists and the United States as bad unilateralists: The BBC reports how the book was written: The 10 authors did not encounter major difficulties, according to France's Le Figaro newspaper. Paradoxically it was not World War II which provided the main topic of debate, but the US role in the world since 1945, the newspaper said. It quoted Guillaume Le Quintrec, co-director of the project, who said "the French found the Germans to be pro-American and the Germans found our viewpoint anti-American". Heated discussions, in which each word was carefully considered, resulted in a text which both sides judged to be "balanced".MORE ABOUT FRENCH EDUCATION: Bushisms are well known and Sirocco reminds us of the embarrassing, but harmless "Grecians," "Kosovarians" or "East Timorians" and links to President Bush confusing Sweden with Switzerland, but France's Foreign Minister is much worse, if the Le Monde is correct. The IHT writes: He has confused Taiwan with Thailand and Croatia with Kosovo and speaks no foreign language - not even English. Indeed, so gaffe-prone is the French foreign minister, Philippe Douste-Blazy, that President Jacques Chirac routinely orders a civil servant to follow him around with a recording device to keep track of all potential mishaps, according to a scathing account in the newspaper Le Monde. (...)More about Douste-Blazy at the Transatlantic Intelligencer. Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry
No Trackbacks
Comments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
David
- #1 - 2006-05-05 22:21 - (Reply)
How can you say that American high school education is "US-Centric" when the respondents thought the US population was "between 1 and 2 billion" and 11% couldn't even find the US on the map? Comments ()
Thomas
- #1.1 - 2006-05-08 19:37 - (Reply)
If you are US-centric, you do not care about world maps. However, don't forget "reality has a well-known liberal bias (Stephan Colbert). Comments ()
joe
- #2 - 2006-05-07 19:21 - (Reply)
David, Comments ()
Thomas
- #2.1 - 2006-05-08 19:41 - (Reply)
If US citizens don't even know where Iraq is, they probably don't know much else either. This means they can't make informed decisions about going to war. Comments ()
joe
- #3 - 2006-05-09 01:29 - (Reply)
Thomas, Comments ()
Jorg
- #4 - 2006-05-09 10:29 - (Reply)
There was not an advertising campaign of that name. Comments ()
beth
- #6 - 2006-05-17 04:50 - (Reply)
Interesting post and comments. I can't speak for ALL Americans, of course, but I can find Iraq on a map. Just so you know :) we aren't ALL that ignorant. Comments ()
John
- #7 - 2006-05-22 00:05 - (Reply)
Of course most Germans would say that the US was no better than the USSR at the end of the war. Germans would never, ever burn Russian flags in the streets as they burn American ones. Germans spit on America for the wars in Iraq and Vietnam, but they don't seem to worry about what the Soviets did in East Europe (I don't expect Germans to give a shit about what happens to Slavs or anyone living in that area of the world) or Afghanistan. And that is what you call respect. Comments ()
littleandy
- #7.1 - 2006-06-01 08:53 - (Reply)
Sorry, John, but you generalize in a way, that's as dangerous as the general anti-Americanism you can find in German (and other) media. Not all Germans are anti-American, not all Germans are unthankful for American aid. Comments ()
littleandy
- #8 - 2006-06-01 08:59 - (Reply)
By the way, I think missing geographical knowledge of other regions is not a US-problem, but a general problem. Most people in Germany wouldn't know, where Utah or Missouri is (just for example), at least I think so. And that's the same for many of the Southern American or African countries. So I think, that's something, Germans and Americans have in common :-) Comments ()
proud kaffir
- #9 - 2006-06-20 09:00 - (Reply)
I saw a tv show once in France. They were conducting a street interview in Germany about general geography. It was interesting to not that almost no one could name all of the countries that border their own country. Some very interesting responses were Alsace, Portugal, and Spain. And in a recent survery of the French, 2/3rds thought that Neil Armstrong's moonwalk was only a movie that never actually took place. Comments ()
Ingo Dierck
- #9.1 - 2006-06-28 17:18 - (Reply)
Well, talking of Alsace as a neighbour of Germany is not completely wrong. Comments ()
Taffy Curtis
- #10 - 2007-12-18 21:05 - (Reply)
You know what? The anti-American stance of France and Germany is so old news it is hard to believe that people are being paid to write about it. Of course these countries are ethnocentric! It is basic human nature to be ethnocentric. Comments ()
|
Contact UsEmail Joerg Wolf and Kyle Atwell at:
ar-team AT atlanticreview.org We are available for interviews, and appreciate feedback and suggestions. Subscribe and FollowWelcome!
You are reading the ATLANTIC REVIEW, a Press Digest on Transatlantic Relations combined with commentary and analysis. More about us. Follow Atlantic Review on Facebook or on Twitter. Subscribe to one of our RSS-Feeds or to our newsletter. SponsorSUPPORT THIS SITEBlogrollHot TopicsClick on one of the following links to see all Atlantic Review posts about this topic in a chronological order with the latest post on top:
Afghanistan Anti-Americanism Economics Iran Iraq Merkel Polls Terrorism Click here for the full list of all topics. |
Home - About Us - Newsletter - Transatlantic Relations - US Foreign Policy - Various RSS Feeds Designed for Atlantic Review by Carl.

